Kim Kardashian has taken aim at critics who panned her latest TV drama by sharing screenshots of fans deciding to watch the series despite scathing reviews.

She stars as a divorce lawyer in the Disney+ series All’s Fair, which received extremely negative reviews. The Guardian called it “so awful, it feels almost contemptuous,” while The Times labeled it “possibly the worst TV drama ever.”

Kardashian addressed her 354 million Instagram followers: “Have you tuned in to the most critically acclaimed show of the year!?!?!? All’s Fair streaming now.”

Currently, the series has a 5% critic score on Rotten Tomatoes, though it holds a 66% audience rating.

Fan Reactions Turned the Tide

Despite negative reviews, Kardashian highlighted fans’ posts showing enthusiasm for the show:

• One fan joked that critics’ harsh reviews actually encouraged people to watch and enjoy the series.
• Another remarked on the star-studded cast, saying All’s Fair “dares to ask the question ‘does a show need to be good?’ and the answer is no.”
• Fans praised the participation of Sarah Paulson, Naomi Watts, Glenn Close, Niecy Nash, and Teyana Taylor, calling their performances “amazeballs” despite critical disappointment.

Critics vs. Reality Star

This is Kardashian’s second acting role after appearing in 2023’s American Horror Story Season 12, where she received mostly positive feedback. All’s Fair reunites her with showrunner Ryan Murphy, known for Glee and Pose.

Critics were unforgiving. The Huffington Post described the series as “torn apart,” with some giving zero out of five stars. Variety’s Alison Herman called it “a clumsy, condescending take on rah-rah girlboss feminism.” The Hollywood Reporter’s Angie Han criticized Kardashian as an “appropriately wooden lead for Ryan Murphy’s empty, unforgivably dull drama.”

Despite this, Kardashian showcased fans’ reactions praising the show’s predictability and styling humorously, emphasizing audience enjoyment over critics’ opinions.

Global Popularity

Kardashian concluded her Instagram post by highlighting the show’s worldwide success. All’s Fair is currently the most-watched title on Disney+, ranking first in 28 countries, including the United States. Fans continue to stream the series enthusiastically, demonstrating that audience interest can differ sharply from critical reception.